Re: High baritone/low tenor songs?
Let me think...
Many songs from Titanic fit that bill (In Every Age, Barrett's Song)
Finishing the Hat - Sunday in the Park with George
High Flying Adored - Evita
Molasses to Rum - 1776
Johanna - Sweeney Todd (okay, it's pretty flatly a baritone song, but Anthony is cast as a tenor all the time)
This Is Not Over Yet - Parade
Nobody Needs to Know - The Last Five Years
Music of the Night - Phantom of the Opera
Me - Beauty and the Beast
Empty Chairs at Empty Tables - Les Miserables
Soliloquy and The Highest Judge of All - Carousel
If You Want to Die in Bed - Miss Saigon