Musicals.Net
http://musicals.net/forums/

Best/Worst by show
http://musicals.net/forums/viewtopic.php?f=91&t=78926
Page 2 of 2

Author:  thewrongtime [ Wed Jan 26, 2011 7:37 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Best/Worst by show

OKLAHOMA!
Best Melody - Many a New Day
Best Lyrics- People Will Say We're In Love
Worst Melody- Not sure.
Worst Lyrics- Oklahoma!

CAROUSEL
Best Melody- If I Loved You
Best Lyrics- Soliloquy
Worst Melody- You'll Never Walk Alone
Worst Lyrics- A Real Nice Clambake

SOUTH PACIFIC
Best Melody- Some Enchanted Evening
Best Lyrics- You've Got to Be Carefully Taught
Worst Melody- Twin Soliloquies (nothing against this song - I actually quite like it)
Worst Lyrics- Happy Talk

THE KING AND I
Best Melody- Shall We Dance
Best Lyrics- Something Wonderful
Worst Melody- We Kiss in a Shadow
Worst Lyrics- Getting to Know You or I Whistle a Happy Tune

SOUND OF MUSIC
Best Melody-The Sound of Music
Best Lyrics- Maria
Worst Melody- Climb Every Mountain
Worst Lyrics- Do-Re-Mi

CINDERELLA
Best Melody- Do I Love You Because You're Beautiful?
Best Lyrics- Ten Minutes Ago
Worst Melody- Boys and Girls Like You and Me
Worst Lyrics- Impossible

Author:  Quique [ Thu Feb 24, 2011 10:42 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Best/Worst by show

So this is basically...a contest.

Best this, worst that. You're good, you suck. "You're goin' to Hollywood!", you can't sing yourself outta paper bag.

How about "this is my favorite melody/lyric, and this explains why" and "this is my least favorite melody/lyric, and I will tell you why."

That way, all unnecessary provocation is left out because you would have explained a "least fave" doesn't mean "worst."

Focus would be on music and lyric writing, which I'm sure was the intention of this thread, eh? :P

Author:  High-baritonne [ Sun Mar 13, 2011 5:17 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Best/Worst by show

Quique wrote:
So this is basically...a contest.

Best this, worst that. You're good, you suck. "You're goin' to Hollywood!", you can't sing yourself outta paper bag.

How about "this is my favorite melody/lyric, and this explains why" and "this is my least favorite melody/lyric, and I will tell you why."

That way, all unnecessary provocation is left out because you would have explained a "least fave" doesn't mean "worst."

Focus would be on music and lyric writing, which I'm sure was the intention of this thread, eh? :P


Yes, please! I really dislike when people claim something to be good or bad without explanation. I am not saying that I never do this myself, because I do, and I hate it, but expressing what we like and dislike rather than what we think is good and bad would be brilliant!

Author:  gabriellivingston [ Mon Jun 27, 2011 1:40 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Best/Worst by show

CINDERELLA
Best Melody: Impossible
Best Lyrics: Eith Impossible (but the World is Full Of Zanys and Fools: Poetic and Perfect!) or In My Own Little Corner (very creative)
Worst Melody: The Prince is Giving a Ball
Worst Lyrics: Do I Love You Because You're Beautiful?

SOUTH PACIFIC
Best Melody: I'm In Love With A Wonderful Guy
Best Lyrics: A Cockeyed Optimist
Worst Melody: Twin Soliloquies
Worst Lyrics: Bloody Mary

THE KING AND I
Best Melody: Shall We Dance?
Best Lyrics: Hello, Young Lovers
Worst Melody: A Puzzlment
Worst Lyrics: Something Wonderful (I know, I'm getting killed for that.)

THE SOUND OF MUSIC
Best Melody: The Sound of Music
Best Lyrics: Something Good
Worst Melody: No Way To Stop It
Worst Lyrics: Do-Rei-Mi

Page 2 of 2 All times are UTC - 8 hours [ DST ]
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group
http://www.phpbb.com/