Archive for Musicals.Net Musicals.Net
 


       Musicals.Net Forums -> The MdN Social Club
Lepitot

Wall-E

Everyone needs to go see this film NOW.

I just saw it, and it is absolutely beautiful. The relationship between Wall-E and Eve is so adorable and touching. I seriously almost cried like five times.

As with all Pixar films, it was rendered beautifully. The animation is stunning, the colors and lighting were fabulous. Such a stunning work of art.

GO SEE IT!

(And post reviews!)
Mungojerrie_rt

I've seen a trailer for it. I don't get how it could be dragged out to a full movie, with no dialogue and all. How long is it?
Lepitot

It's 1 hour and 55 minutes. But, believe me, there is plenty of story.

And, it's Pixar. They could take talking meatballs and turn it into a 2 hour movie that has a 90 percent freshness rating and rave reviews and makes over 250 million.

It has a lot of messages in it...

And, there isn't a ton of dialogue, but there's a decent amount. That's the beauty of a well-made animated film, the story moves fluidly without dialogue...the actions express all the emotion you need to know.
shakalakababy

I adore this movie. One of pixars best. it was just beautiful. and i loved how all the humans were really fat
mizzie

I'm seeing this tomorrow with my brother and his girlfriend, who is a scientist-to-be and is SO excited.

It looks really adorable, but I'm not going to lie...I want to be lame and see Get Smart instead!
shakalakababy

oh and can i just say i love all the random hello dolly clips in the movie. totally caught me by suprise but it worked really well
LittleGavroche

The trailers do not do the film justice. I think the trailers are really Disney trying to market the film to children. It's not a children's film. At all. It's a beautiful satire that just happens to be animated.

Really, I love the movie. And this board should like the "Hello, Dolly!" references. Wink

Oh, and stay for the credits. They are a little tag to the story.
mizzie

Hello, Dolly! references!?!?!?!?

I'M SO IN.
Dax

I swear they can get more emotion out of a pair of computer-animated robots and a handful of sounds than most can get out of real actors.

[spoiler]








When Wall-E was getting crushed by the analyzer and Eve was trying to lift it, begging, "Please, please" was heartwrenching.

And then there was the end credits; as they chronicle human re-habitation with cave paintings up through contemporary art was very clever. Low-tech art for the height of human technology which increases in style as humans progress taking back the land though less industrialization.


[/spoiler]
Nudelkopf

Probably won't come to my tiny town for another 6months. No, really.
Mungojerrie_rt

It's opening here very soon. But then, I do live in the third biggest city in the country.

Get Smart is hillarious.
Lepitot

get Smart was funny, but it left a lot to be desired.

Wall-E is, from both a critic and viewer standpoint (those who have seen the film) one of the best films of 2008.

I won't care if you don't like it once you see it. But, give it a chance man lol.
Salome

It looks wonderful! I'm seeinmg it this weekend.

oh..and Mizzie dont be embarassed about wanting to see Get Smart. Its very fun. and Steve Carrell and Alan Arkin are great. the only problem with it is that Mel Brooks and Buck Henry disnt write the screenplay.
pish123c

"Wall-E" is a great film. Adorable and still manages to have a message that is relevant today. It kind of depressed me, but all of the cute robot love compensated for that.
Lepitot

pish123c wrote:
"Wall-E" is a great film. Adorable and still manages to have a message that is relevant today. It kind of depressed me, but all of the cute robot love compensated for that.


hahaha, yes!

It made me want to go run 3 miles every day lol.
Set_Buildin_Dad

Salome wrote:
It looks wonderful! I'm seeinmg it this weekend.

oh..and Mizzie dont be embarassed about wanting to see Get Smart. Its very fun. and Steve Carrell and Alan Arkin are great. the only problem with it is that Mel Brooks and Buck Henry disnt write the screenplay.


I agree about Get Smart. My whole family loved it. Just don't go expecting to see Don Adams take on the character or the simpler writing styles used in the 60s for the small screen.

I am going to try to see Wall-E this weekend as well. Everything I've heard about is so far is great.
Mungojerrie_rt

Set_Buildin_Dad wrote:
Salome wrote:
It looks wonderful! I'm seeinmg it this weekend.

oh..and Mizzie dont be embarassed about wanting to see Get Smart. Its very fun. and Steve Carrell and Alan Arkin are great. the only problem with it is that Mel Brooks and Buck Henry disnt write the screenplay.


I agree about Get Smart. My whole family loved it. Just don't go expecting to see Don Adams take on the character or the simpler writing styles used in the 60s for the small screen.


It's a very good thing he isn't trying to immitate Don Adams. You just can't. It's better to be good with your own take on the character than try to immitate the master and fail.
Salome

I agree with that statement. but i still think the film could have benefitted by Mel Brooks and Buck Henry. I find it odd they werent asked.
Mungojerrie_rt

They were "Consultants" whatever that means.
Salome

It means that considering they created the characters and show they were asked for advice.
Mungojerrie_rt

It doesn't mean they were listened to. I was still very funny though.
Salome

It was very funny and I thinmk it wasw a good homage. but it would have been better with some Brooks/Henry humor.
BroadwayObssessed

Lepitot wrote:


And, it's Pixar. They could take talking meatballs and turn it into a 2 hour movie that has a 90 percent freshness rating and rave reviews and makes over 250 million.



That statement instantly made me think of the chihuahua movie that's coming out in a couple months. Very Happy


http://youtube.com/watch?v=0mI808JK6-Q
^^^For people who have no idea what I'm talking about
pish123c

Lepitot wrote:
pish123c wrote:
"Wall-E" is a great film. Adorable and still manages to have a message that is relevant today. It kind of depressed me, but all of the cute robot love compensated for that.


hahaha, yes!

It made me want to go run 3 miles every day lol.

Same here.

"Hey! We have a pool!?" Laughing
Pannic

I loved it. Probably Pixar's best movie to date.
candymancan

This movie was so ridiculously good! And the funny thing was I didn't realize there was a tiny pit of Dialogue. It wasn't till after the movie that my friends mentioned it that I realized there wasn't much.

It was so funny and good! I loved every moment of it! Oh and if you need a movie to go on a date to see this.

I loved all the Hello, Dolly! stuff. It made me so happy! The end credits were genius as well. My other friend who wants to become an Art History major loved it and so did I. I loved how it was the art styles through the ages.
pish123c

candymancan wrote:
And the funny thing was I didn't realize there was a tiny pit of Dialogue. It wasn't till after the movie that my friends mentioned it that I realized there wasn't much.


It took a while for that to really hit me as well.
Bianca.

this movie was AMAZING.

first of all, it was SO FREAKING ADORABLE,

but moreso, the political allusions and satire were so well done.

I loved this film.


So much.

just incredible. I can't even put it into words.



Get Smart was funny.. and Anne Hathaway is HOT... but really... it was just another typical movie.


Wall-e was phenomenal.
Vice

Mmmm... I've wanted to see this for FOREVER. I love the newer Pixar movies (i.e. newer than Monster's Inc.) and I know that Ratatouille(sp?) made me feel fuzzy on the inside.
(Also any company that does kickass Miyazaki dubs, AND gets them into american theaters... Is AWESOME.)

I'm just so amazed that Pixar can make robots aborable.
...
But I mean it's Pixar. Which rocks.
LittleGavroche

Vice wrote:
Mmmm... I've wanted to see this for FOREVER. I love the newer Pixar movies (i.e. newer than Monster's Inc.) and I know that Ratatouille(sp?) made me feel fuzzy on the inside.
(Also any company that does kickass Miyazaki dubs, AND gets them into american theaters... Is AWESOME.)

I'm just so amazed that Pixar can make robots aborable.
...
But I mean it's Pixar. Which rocks.


Ratatouille is still my favorite Pixar film. Just makes me feel so warm and fuzzy. And it had such a perfect cast. Ian Holm rocked Chef Skinner.

Pixar has yet to make a bad film in my book.
BroadwayObssessed

LittleGavroche wrote:
Vice wrote:
Mmmm... I've wanted to see this for FOREVER. I love the newer Pixar movies (i.e. newer than Monster's Inc.) and I know that Ratatouille(sp?) made me feel fuzzy on the inside.
(Also any company that does kickass Miyazaki dubs, AND gets them into american theaters... Is AWESOME.)

I'm just so amazed that Pixar can make robots aborable.
...
But I mean it's Pixar. Which rocks.


Ratatouille is still my favorite Pixar film. Just makes me feel so warm and fuzzy. And it had such a perfect cast. Ian Holm rocked Chef Skinner.

Pixar has yet to make a bad film in my book.


"A Bug's Life" was really boring...for me, atleast... Confused
LittleGavroche

I don't have a problem with A Bug's Life. Technically, the film is beautiful, and I love the quirky characters. I can see why some might not like it. But in my opinion, it is better than most of the films that come out of Hollywood these days.
candymancan

LittleGavroche wrote:
Pixar has yet to make a bad film in my book.


I completely agree! That is why I love any Pixar movie that comes out because there hasn't been a bad one yet!

My favorites are Monster's Inc. and The Incredibles! I love those two!
mizzie

SO. CUTE.

I mean, it was just completely adorable in every way.

The animation was just perfection, and I loved how it meshed both real and animated film together, showing the development of humans. The movie really had a point, but it wasn't preaching to the little kids.

Unfortunately, I did have some trouble concentrating, as my OCD has been especially bad lately and I can't stop fidgeting.

Still, it was just the SWEETEST film. It was so creative! And who else loved the animated short before it started (with the magician)? So funny. The whole thing was hilarious.

Who else cried at the (almost) ending?

The hand holding stuff was beautiful. When I looked over to my brother and girlfriend they were starting to hold hands to follow suit with the characters. Made the experience especially sweet for me.

Plus, all the Hello, Dolly! stuff was hilarious to me. And my family (who I saw it with). I wasn't expecting so much of it, though! And the art at the end was brilliant - who else got super excited when they saw the George Seurat-esque painting of the boy fishing? It made me happy.

"Put on your Sunday clothes..."
Lepitot

I almost cried at the ending. I would have if I hadn't been stopping myself.

Pixar really hasn't made a bad film, especially when you compare it to other company movies.

The worst movie they came out with was Cars, and it still has an 85 percent fresh rating on RottenTomatoes. And, one critic summed it up perfectly, by saying something along the lines of, "Not quite a up to previous Pixar standards, but compared to other animated films by other companies, it's a hit!"

My favorites go:

1) Wall-E (or Incredibles, can't decide)
2) ^whichever doesn't take Number 1
3) Monsters, Inc.
sopranoopianoo

I took my little brother and sister to see it today!!

They LOVED it, and so did I. I was so excited about the hello dolly parts... and i'll admit I got teary-eyed several times.

This movie made me realize at how far we have come with technology... every little detail of this movie is incredible... so realistic. I loved the messages that were portrayed in the film as well. Very Happy

And my little brother & sister got free Wall-E watches when we bought tickets... they loved that!
kozafluitmusique

I really want to see it, and will see it soon. Glad it's gotten positive remarks!
opheliarose

I can't get past the resemblance to Number 5.

Yeah, I'm that old.
BroadwayObssessed

opheliarose wrote:
I can't get past the resemblance to Number 5.


ME TOO! (If you're referring to Johnny Five that is).... Smile ...At the very early commercials, where they barely told you anything about the movie, I thought it was a animated remake of Short Circuit. Embarassed
Set_Buildin_Dad

opheliarose wrote:
I can't get past the resemblance to Number 5.

Yeah, I'm that old.


My wife and I said exactly the same thing when we first saw the posters in the theatre. Number 5 is indeed alive again.
Anno_Domini

lol I love how AUTO (the auto-pilot/villain) was actually voiced by a computer. Macbook is quite the actor
LittleGavroche

Lepitot wrote:


The worst movie they came out with was Cars, and it still has an 85 percent fresh rating on RottenTomatoes. And, one critic summed it up perfectly, by saying something along the lines of, "Not quite a up to previous Pixar standards, but compared to other animated films by other companies, it's a hit!"



Awh, I like Cars too. I actually cried during it. I cried over the relationship between two cars.

Wow. I am a sucker.
Lepitot

I watched an hour of Wall-E today before work and just marvelled at the animation.

SO incredible.

The reflections in Eve's body are incredible. When Wall-E first takes her into his little space, the reflections of all the the objects, lights were phenomenal.

And, everything Wall-E does is animated so well.

And his voice, is so adorable/ heart breaking. Everytime he says, "eva?" my heart melts lol.
Theaterfan101

just saw and loved this movie. spoilersI swear I was holding tears in starting when wall-e got crushed, then couldn't remember eve when she reformed him. The end credits as well excellent, so smart. end spoilers
What wasn't fun was having to explain the whole movie in detail to my parents the car ride home. Neither one of them understood anything in the movie. Not a single thing.
kakoforever

Neither did mine! They couldn't get over that they were robots.
Nudelkopf

I don't enjoy Pixar movies Confused

They're the type of films that a lot of people can watch over and over again, but if I ever saw a movie twice I'd scream. (Except for The Prestige, I actually want to see that again - will be the first movie I think I've ever watched twice)
jcstar

opheliarose wrote:
I can't get past the resemblance to Number 5.

Yeah, I'm that old.


As am I. I looked at the trailors and the poster(s) and said "Wait a minute! That's Johnny 5!"

I then went home and watched SHORT CIRCUIT... that just happened to be on TV at the time.

Sadly, it's not coming to my town.

Andy.
Theaterfan101

Who is number 5?
BroadwayObssessed

Theaterfan101 wrote:
Who is number 5?


The robot in the movie Short Circuit's name is Johnny Five, but in the movie he frequently refers to himself as Number Five if I remember correctly.
LittleGavroche

Nudelkopf wrote:
(Except for The Prestige, I actually want to see that again - will be the first movie I think I've ever watched twice)


I think The Prestige is really something you have to watch again, to understand each little nuance of the plot.
Dax


Johnny 5
sopranodespair

I just saw Wall-E with my sister and grandparents. It was so cute! The romance was just so sweet, and Wall-E's clumsiness and character in general was adorable. I love the Hello Dolly clips. I love pretty much every Pixar movie. The only ones I don't like are Cars and A Bugs Life.
Annie

Just got home from seeing it.

Absolutely incredible. INCREDIBLE.

I'm a total sucker all the time, so it's no surprise that I cried like a baby all the way through.
Loneliness in movies, and punches of terrifying, conceivable reality in off-the-wall concepts get me the most - which pretty much comprised Wall-E completely!

My first waterfall was at the very beginning when he closed up and went to sleep on his shelf next to the little cricket guy, and stuck his hand out to push off the floor to make the shelf rock them to sleep. I burst into tears.

I'm lame.



But anyway, the movie was just LOVELY. Absolutely amazing film. Everyone should see it.
kakoforever

I actually love the soundtrack. It's one of those things that you don't really appreciate until you listen on its own. "Define Dancing" is my favorite. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ellu5xXNmYs
fjays

aww! i can't wait to see it!
but it doesnt come out in aus till late september Sad

sounds amazing though!
Eponine_Thénardier_08

So at first I was not wanting to see this
( I thought it was going to be some cheesy thing )
But now that I have read so many good reviews and one of my friends said that it was good I really want too see this.

Also Hello Dolly clips?...............COUNT ME IN! Smile
Salome

Nudelkopf wrote:
I don't enjoy Pixar movies Confused

They're the type of films that a lot of people can watch over and over again, but if I ever saw a movie twice I'd scream.)[/size]


Movies are a form of art. you cant watch a film once you need to watch over and over and find new things.
its like ap ianting or ap iece of poetry. you always find soemthing new..in a performance, a color a piece of cinematography.
kozafluitmusique

I thought the film was so cute! i need to see it again, though.

I loved "Presto" as well.
Theaterfan101

I just came back from seeing round two. This time with the majority of my summer program. We all loved it, even the ones you would think would hate it or not admit their like. Any way I noticed so many more things from seeing it again.


Also trailers (assuming they are mostly the same at every theater because I got the same rounds in two diffrent time zones)

Beverly Hills Chihuahua ..... how does that movie get made?
Annie

the credits song, "Down to Earth".....beautiful.

I can't wait to see it again, and bring my mom! Very Happy
DontDoSadnessxx

saw it again tonight.
soooo good =]
jarrod001

I saw it today and it was incredible!
I got scared because what if that's what we become?
Fat and lazy in our chairs and we have everything done for us.
I LOVED the fatty pile up when the ship tipped over.
gdawg22

this was seriously one of the best movies that i have seen in a while.
thank you pixar for another amazing movie!
if you have not had the chance to see it, do it as soon as possible.
Mr. Green
Pounce

I liked WALL-E but to me Ratatouille is a much smarter film. And for pure entertainment, The Incredibles is probably Pixar's best. Films that I like a lot, I want to see again and I'm fine with seeing Wall-E once. Pixar is getting better technically with each film and while Toy Story was excellent I still had a sense that it was computer animation. With WALL-E I pretty much forgot it was computer generated save for the scenes with humans. And yes, sit through the closing credits, plus Peter Gabriel's song is good. I also liked the short Presto at the beginning but it is heavy on old fashioned physical comedy which doesn't get the best laughs out of me. Anyway, for me, it's a good film but not great.

Spoilers

The allusion to 2001 was fun complete with its theme music but it made it a bit predictable. The relationship between Wall-E and Eve seemed a bit odd in that Wall-E was perhaps desperately lonely and was infatuated rather than in love. And exactly how is Wall-E male and Eve female? The space dance was cute and their functioning in space makes sense but exposing a plant in space would kill it immediately. The theme of saving and protecting our planet, excessive consumerism, etc is a bit old. I'm just glad it didn't do the "evil corporation" cliche.

End of Spoilers

And from the trailers, the Chihuahua movie looks about as bad as Underdog.
Pounce

I like this director's thinking

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-lkbqgsrRXg

A lesson for Sondheim to learn. But it's hard not to think about the eco-theme's importance.

A couple of observations with spoiler

I thought the sound of WALL-E starting up sounded familiar and I'm pretty sure it is the old MAC boot-up "gong". And I'm a bit unsure about WALL-E's memory recovery. Maybe they could have had EVE discover a backup drive to restore him instead. A good practical "lesson" to us all. Not even love can recover lost data.

end of spoiler
Lepitot

How is Ratatouille a much smarter film, might I ask? It's a wonderful movie, but it's a film that I haven't watched all the way through since I saw it in theatres. I mean, it's well written, beautifully animated...but, it's still a story about a rat who can cook. And the whole pulling his hair and moving his arms like a puppet never really worked for me. I love the monologue at the end, and it does have a nice message, but I just can't see it being more intelligent than Wall-E.

In my opinion (and you are certainly allowed to have your own) Wall-E is the most mature, intelligent film by Pixar. It's just so profound and beautiful. Ratatouille, while a good film, isn't (at least not in my opinion.)

I agree about The INcredibles being the most fun in pure entertainment. In fact, I think The Incredibles has the tightest storyline of all the Pixar films.
Pounce

Well, for one Ratatouille was directed by Brad Bird. Arguably the best animation director around. And a common complaint I heard from parents is their children were bored by the movie because it was too sophisticated. The film also had a phenomenal attention to detail in how a gourmet french restaurant works. Professional cooks everywhere were blown away by its accuracy. I myself was very impressed in how the dialog and story were crafted and Brad Bird did a brilliant execution. I don't know how unique Ratatouille is but there are not many films quite like it and I found the challenge of creating a film with a culinary theme intriguing. I really think the film is for adults.

But I think you missed the point about the film. It was not just a story about a rat who can cook. A child would get that much. It was about following your passion no matter what. Remy obviously had severe limitations and would be among the most despised inhabitants in a kitchen. French chefs, known for their egos, did find some satisfaction in being poked fun at by the suggestion that of all things, a rat, outdoing them in the culinary arts. A nice reminder that we might find greatness in the most unsuspecting places.

I'd be interested in what you found to be so mature and profound in WALL-E. To me it was mostly about a lonely, love-sick robot chasing after a 'girl' which gets complicated as his 'path' crosses others' lives.
Lepitot

Yes, Brad Bird is phenomenal. And, while Ratatouille is a great film, I'd take The Iron Giant and The Incredibles over it any day.

And, yes, Ratatouille does have a deeper message, and it is a nice one. But, to me, despite the message, I can't sit through it, at least not all in one go. It's just not my kind of movie, I guess.

As for Wall-E...

It's so much more than a simple love story, or a kiddy movie. For one, it's a satire. And, if you are going just on the love story bit, critics have said that it's the most beautiful and moving love story since Jack and Rose in Titanic. It is also the most serious of all the Pixar movies.

I wouldn't be surprised if kids enjoyed Ratatouille more than Wall-E. Because, Wall-E is very boring if you don't possess the brain power to dig deeper into it. Wall-E is practically a silent film. And even though the animation is entertaining, kids are restless. Ratatouille has a story that is easier, and more interesting to them, to understand.
LesMisForever

I saw it today.

It is a "cute" movie. In essence, it is a love story. I don't think this movie is for very small children. I don't think they will see past the animations.

I agree with those admiring the animations, and how it kept our attention virtually without dialogues. If anything, i felt the dialogues scenes were weaker.

Even though both "leads" lol were great, i thought that little Robot Cleaner was the cutest of them all.
Pounce

Lepitot wrote:
Yes, Brad Bird is phenomenal. And, while Ratatouille is a great film, I'd take The Iron Giant and The Incredibles over it any day.

And, yes, Ratatouille does have a deeper message, and it is a nice one. But, to me, despite the message, I can't sit through it, at least not all in one go. It's just not my kind of movie, I guess.

Fair enough. I even agree that The Incredibles and The Iron Giant were better but that is no slight on Ratatouille.

Quote:
As for Wall-E...

It's so much more than a simple love story, or a kiddy movie. For one, it's a satire. And, if you are going just on the love story bit, critics have said that it's the most beautiful and moving love story since Jack and Rose in Titanic. It is also the most serious of all the Pixar movies.

I wouldn't be surprised if kids enjoyed Ratatouille more than Wall-E. Because, Wall-E is very boring if you don't possess the brain power to dig deeper into it. Wall-E is practically a silent film. And even though the animation is entertaining, kids are restless. Ratatouille has a story that is easier, and more interesting to them, to understand.

I think it's just the opposite. It's more of a "lust story" at least on the part of Wall-E. He knows nothing of Eve and seems to be attracted more out of desperation in his loneliness for a connection with "one of his own kind". And this sort of characters bonding through adventure is so "been there done that". Personally, I didn't buy the idea that the characters "fall in love". And I don't think its satirical elements are so strong as to classify Wall-E as satire.

I haven't heard much in the way of parental feedback for Wall-E but I think Wall-E's story is more accessible to children than Ratatouille. As I said before, a common complaint by parents is that their kids got easily bored by Ratatouille because of the story's sophistication. I think it is among the smartest of animated film's I've ever seen. With Wall-E, kids are not burdened by dialog and can take in the story through visuals. Language is a higher form of communication and I'm sure Stanton was aware of the limitations when dialog is removed. Humans and talking robots provide the needed exposition. Really, Wall-E is like watching a dog movie (with no talking dogs) with loving, faithful Wall-E playing the 'dog'.
Dax

Roger Ebert writing in the Chicago Sun-Times said WALL-E succeeded in three areas: as "an enthralling animated film, a visual wonderment, and a decent science-fiction story".
Ebert said the scarcity of dialogue would allow it to "cross language barriers" in a manner appropriate to the global theme, and he had praise for the visual effects, saying the color palette was "bright and cheerful... and a little bit realistic".
He cited early Disney animations that successfully translated human expressions onto non-human characters as an influence on the title character. He said the film managed to generate a "curious" regard for the WALL-E, comparing his design ("rusty and hard-working and plucky") favorably to more obvious attempts at creating "lovable" lead characters. Ebert called the storytelling "enchanting" and said the film could be enjoyed by adults and children alike.

He said WALL-E was concerned with ideas rather than spectacle, saying it may require "a little thought" on the part of the audience, and that this could be particularly stimulating to younger viewers


It does require a bit more thinking...

So if all you see is a lovesick robot...well, you're missing out.

Among other things, I saw a robot learning emotion. And the ultimate expression of love was holding another's hand. How poignant.
Pounce

LesMisForever wrote:
I agree with those admiring the animations, and how it kept our attention virtually without dialogues. If anything, i felt the dialogues scenes were weaker.

The dialog scenes are for exposition and support.

Quote:
Even though both "leads" lol were great, i thought that little Robot Cleaner was the cutest of them all.

I agree. That is the essence of robot comedy. A machine with an obsessive fixation to duty but with behavior bordering on human. Laughing
wicked_diva

I still really need to see this!

But my favorite Pixar (and one of my favorite movies) is Cars. The characters in there are very real, and I think the story is very important. It also inspired us to drive Route 66 (or what's left of it) when we trekked out to Oklahoma for school in 06. Seeing places like Amboy, which is what Radiator Springs is based on, you can tell how much research and detail went into Cars (and Amboy is one of the saddest places ever - completely abandoned, even a church and school, just because of I-40). It's a wonderful movie and very close to my heart.
Pounce

Dax wrote:
He said WALL-E was concerned with ideas rather than spectacle, saying it may require "a little thought" on the part of the audience, and that this could be particularly stimulating to younger viewers[/i]

It does require a bit more thinking...

So if all you see is a lovesick robot...well, you're missing out.

Among other things, I saw a robot learning emotion. And the ultimate expression of love was holding another's hand. How poignant.

Even the director said it's a love story and deals with relationships. Not a lot more than that. What more should one take away from the film? I don't think there is anything particularly significant in Wall-E learning emotion other than as an expository element to the plot of this robot having feelings for another robot. Holding hands is all that he knew. One shouldn't walk away from the film thinking "robots are people too". Wall-E developing emotion was just a useful device to the story and apparently it is explained though his repeated viewings of Hello Dolly. I wonder what Wall-E would have done had he found a porno film instead? Laughing
LesMisForever

I am not sure whether my opinion is influenced by age, but i don't think Wall-E is an exceptional movie. Maybe amongst animations, i don't know. I don't really watch that many to judge.

I am not trying to knock it down. I enjoyed it, and was entertained by it, but it is not something i will still talk about next week.
Pounce

While certainly cutting edge in computer animation, Pixar is really more concerned with Classical Hollywood Cinema in its storytelling.

spoiler alert
If Pixar wanted to be New Hollywood or some other form of film-making, they could have ended it with Wall-E having no recollection of Eve and losing all his personality and reverting back to a trash compactor robot. Eve, despondent knowing love but no one to share it with, self-destructs and the uncaring Wall-E gathers up her remains, compresses her and stacks her with the other garbage. Hmmm...sounds sort of Japanese or even European! Wink
end of spoiler alert
       Musicals.Net Forums -> The MdN Social Club
Page 1 of 1