dolbinau
|
Sweeney actor elimination game.I probably can predict who will win, but I'm more interested in how the others will go. I'm only including the "Major" Sweeneys who have been commercially recorded.
Also so it doesn't drag on It'll just start on 5, which means people only vote once or twice a day not over and over again so the results reflect the forum's not *your* opinion.
Len Cariou 5
George Hearn 5
Constantino Romero 5
Johnny Depp 5
Michael Cerveris 5
|
Salome
|
- cerveris
+ hearn
George Hearn 6
Len Cariou 5
Bob Gunton 5
Dennis Quilley 5
Constantino Romero 5
Johnny Depp 5
Michael Cerveris 4
|
ActingDude17
|
+ Hearn
- Depp
George Hearn 7
Len Cariou 5
Bob Gunton 5
Dennis Quilley 5
Constantino Romero 5
Johnny Depp 4
Michael Cerveris 4
|
Salome
|
+ gunton
- cerveris
George Hearn 7
Bob Gunton 6
Len Cariou 5
Dennis Quilley 5
Constantino Romero 5
Johnny Depp 4
Michael Cerveris 3
|
ActingDude17
|
+ Hearn
- Depp
George Hearn 8
Bob Gunton 6
Len Cariou 5
Dennis Quilley 5
Constantino Romero 5
Johnny Depp 3
Michael Cerveris 3
|
dolbinau
|
- Cerveris
+ Depp
George Hearn 8
Bob Gunton 6
Len Cariou 5
Dennis Quilley 5
Constantino Romero 5
Johnny Depp 4
Michael Cerveris 2
|
Sweeney Hyde
|
+Quilley
-Ceveris
George Hearn 8
Bob Gunton 6
Dennis Quilley 6
Len Cariou 5
Constantino Romero 5
Johnny Depp 4
Michael Cerveris 1
|
ActingDude17
|
+ Hearn
- Cerveris
George Hearn 9
Bob Gunton 6
Dennis Quilley 6
Len Cariou 5
Constantino Romero 5
Johnny Depp 4
|
bellaenchante
|
+Gunton
-Depp
George Hearn 9
Bob Gunton 7
Dennis Quilley 6
Len Cariou 5
Constantino Romero 5
Johnny Depp 3
|
dolbinau
|
| bellaenchante wrote: | +Gunton
-Depp
George Hearn 9
Bob Gunton 7
Dennis Quilley 6
Len Cariou 5
Constantino Romero 5
Johnny Depp 3 |
You weren't even alive when Gunton played this role, and as far as I know there are no boot legs and certainly no commercial recordings- how do you know if he was good or not?
|
High-baritonne
|
| dolbinau wrote: | | bellaenchante wrote: | +Gunton
-Depp
George Hearn 9
Bob Gunton 7
Dennis Quilley 6
Len Cariou 5
Constantino Romero 5
Johnny Depp 3 |
You weren't even alive when Gunton played this role, and as far as I know there are no boot legs and certainly no commercial recordings- how do you know if he was good or not? |
I do not know, and therefore I'll vote him down.
+ Depp
- Gunton
George Hearn 9
Bob Gunton 6
Dennis Quilley 6
Len Cariou 5
Constantino Romero 5
Johnny Depp 4
|
dolbinau
|
George Hearn 9
Bob Gunton 6
Len Cariou 6
Dennis Quilley 5
Constantino Romero 5
Johnny Depp 4
+ Len Cariou
- Dennis Quilley
|
Salome
|
+ quilley
- cariou
George Hearn 9
Bob Gunton 6
Dennis Quilley 6
Len Cariou 5
Constantino Romero 5
Johnny Depp 4
|
ActingDude17
|
+ Hearn
- Depp
George Hearn 10
Bob Gunton 6
Dennis Quilley 6
Len Cariou 5
Constantino Romero 5
Johnny Depp 3
|
dolbinau
|
+ Cariou
- Quilley
George Hearn 10
Bob Gunton 6
Len Cariou 6
Dennis Quilley 5
Constantino Romero 5
Johnny Depp 3
|
Brock07
|
George Hearn 9
Bob Gunton 6
Len Cariou 7
Dennis Quilley 5
Constantino Romero 5
Johnny Depp 3
-Hearn
+Len
|
ActingDude17
|
+ Cariou
- Depp
George Hearn 9
Len Cariou 8
Bob Gunton 6
Dennis Quilley 5
Constantino Romero 5
Johnny Depp 2
|
Brock07
|
Len Cariou 9
George Hearn 8
Bob Gunton 6
Dennis Quilley 5
Constantino Romero 5
Johnny Depp 2
-George
+Len
|
dolbinau
|
Len Cariou 10
George Hearn 8
Bob Gunton 6
Dennis Quilley 5
Constantino Romero 4
Johnny Depp 2
- Romero
+ Cariou
|
Brock07
|
Len Cariou 11
George Hearn 7
Bob Gunton 6
Dennis Quilley 5
Constantino Romero 4
Johnny Depp 2
+Len
-George
|
ILoveToSing2010
|
Len Cariou 11
George Hearn 7
Bob Gunton 7
Dennis Quilley 5
Constantino Romero 4
Johnny Depp 3
+ Bob Gunton
- Johnny Depp
|
Brock07
|
Len Cariou 12
Bob Gunton 7
George Hearn 6
Dennis Quilley 5
Constantino Romero 4
Johnny Depp 3
+Len
-George
|
STRWBRRY
|
+ Hearn
- Depp
Len Cariou 12
Bob Gunton 7
George Hearn 7
Dennis Quilley 5
Constantino Romero 4
Johnny Depp 2
|
Brock07
|
Len Cariou 13
Bob Gunton 7
George Hearn 6
Dennis Quilley 5
Constantino Romero 4
Johnny Depp 2
+Len
-George
|
Salome
|
+ george
- len
Len Cariou 12
Bob Gunton 7
George Hearn 7
Dennis Quilley 5
Constantino Romero 4
Johnny Depp 2
|
Paul W.
|
- cariou
+ gunton
Len Cariou 11
Bob Gunton 8
George Hearn 7
Dennis Quilley 5
Constantino Romero 4
Johnny Depp 2
|
Salome
|
+ George
- Len
Len Cariou 10
George Hearn 8
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 5
Constantino Romero 4
Johnny Depp 2
|
Paul W.
|
- Romero
+ Hearn
Len Cariou 10
George Hearn 9
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 5
Constantino Romero 3
Johnny Depp 2
|
Salome
|
+ hearn
- romano
Len Cariou 10
George Hearn 10
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 5
Constantino Romero 2
Johnny Depp 2
|
Brock07
|
+Len
-George
Len Cariou 11
George Hearn 9
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 5
Constantino Romero 2
Johnny Depp 2
|
Salome
|
- len
+ george
Len Cariou 10
George Hearn 10
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 5
Constantino Romero 2
Johnny Depp 2
|
Paul W.
|
+ Hearn
- Cariou
George Hearn 11
Len Cariou 9
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 5
Constantino Romero 2
Johnny Depp 2
|
Salome
|
+ george
- len
George Hearn 12
Len Cariou 8
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 5
Constantino Romero 2
Johnny Depp 2
|
Brock07
|
George Hearn 11
Len Cariou 9
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 5
Constantino Romero 2
Johnny Depp 2
|
Salome
|
+ hearn
- romero
George Hearn 12
Len Cariou 9
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 5
Johnny Depp 2
Constantino Romero 1
|
Brock07
|
George Hearn 11
Len Cariou 10
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 5
Johnny Depp 2
Constantino Romero 1
|
Salome
|
+ goerge
- len
George Hearn 12
Len Cariou 9
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 5
Johnny Depp 2
Constantino Romero 1
|
dolbinau
|
George Hearn 11
Len Cariou 10
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 5
Johnny Depp 2
Constantino Romero 1
_________________
+ Cariou
- Hearn
|
ActingDude17
|
+ Cariou
- Depp
George Hearn 11
Len Cariou 11
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 5
Johnny Depp 1
Constantino Romero 1
|
Brock07
|
Len Cariou 12
George Hearn 10
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 5
Johnny Depp 1
Constantino Romero 1
|
Salome
|
+ hearn
- romero (gone)
Len Cariou 12
George Hearn 11
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 5
Johnny Depp 1
|
ILoveToSing2010
|
Len Cariou 12
George Hearn 11
Bob Gunton 9
Dennis Quilley 5
+ Bob Gunton
- Johnny Depp
|
Brock07
|
Len Cariou 13
George Hearn 10
Bob Gunton 9
Dennis Quilley 5
|
Disney-Bway27
|
Len Cariou 14
George Hearn 10
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 5
+ Cariou
- Gunton
|
Salome
|
- len
+ george
Len Cariou 13
George Hearn 11
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 5
|
Paul W.
|
- Cariou
+ Hearn
Len Cariou 12
George Hearn 12
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 5
|
Salome
|
+ George
- Len
George Hearn 13
Len Cariou 11
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 5
|
dolbinau
|
+ Cariou
- Hearn
George Hearn 12
Len Cariou 12
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 5
|
ActingDude17
|
+ Cariou
- Quilley
Len Cariou 13
George Hearn 12
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 4
|
Brock07
|
Len Cariou 14
George Hearn 11
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 4
|
LeocadiaBegbick
|
+Hearn
-Cariou
Len Cariou 13
George Hearn 12
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 4
|
ActingDude17
|
+ Cariou
- Quilley
Len Cariou 14
George Hearn 12
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 3
|
STRWBRRY
|
+ Hearn
- Quilley
Len Cariou 14
George Hearn 13
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 2
|
dolbinau
|
+ Cariou
-Hearn
Len Cariou 15
George Hearn 12
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 2
|
Brock07
|
Len Cariou 16
George Hearn 11
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 2
|
Salome
|
+ quilley
- caroiu
Len Cariou 15
George Hearn 11
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 3
|
Paul W.
|
- Cariou
+ Dennis Quilley
Len Cariou 14
George Hearn 11
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 4
|
Salome
|
- cariou
+ hearn
Len Cariou 13
George Hearn 12
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 4
|
Paul W.
|
+ Quilley
- Cariou
Len Cariou 12
George Hearn 12
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 5
|
Salome
|
+ hearn
- cariou
George Hearn 13
Len Cariou 11
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 5
|
Brock07
|
George Hearn 12
Len Cariou 12
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 5
|
Salome
|
- len
+ george
George Hearn 13
Len Cariou 11
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 5
|
ActingDude17
|
+ Cariou
- Quilley
George Hearn 13
Len Cariou 12
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 4
|
dolbinau
|
+ Cariou
- Hearn
George Hearn 12
Len Cariou 13
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 4
_______________
|
ActingDude17
|
+ Cariou
- Quilley
Len Cariou 14
George Hearn 12
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 3
|
Brock07
|
Len Cariou 15
George Hearn 11
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 3
|
ActingDude17
|
+ Cariou
- Quilley
Len Cariou 16
George Hearn 11
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 2
|
Brock07
|
Len Cariou 17
George Hearn 10
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 2
|
ActingDude17
|
+ Cariou
- Quilley
Len Cariou 18
George Hearn 10
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 1
|
Brock07
|
Len Cariou 19
George Hearn 9
Bob Gunton 8
Dennis Quilley 1
|
ActingDude17
|
+ Cariou
- Quilley
Len Cariou 20
George Hearn 9
Bob Gunton 8
|
Brock07
|
Len Cariou 21
George Hearn 8
Bob Gunton 8
|
dolbinau
|
Len Cariou 22
George Hearn 7
Bob Gunton 8
_____________
|
Brock07
|
Len Cariou 23
Bob Gunton 8
George Hearn 6
|
Salome
|
wtf 
have fun guys
|
SomeoneLikeYou
|
Seriously, how is Hearn in last place?
+ George Hearn
- Bob Gunton
Len Cariou 23
Bob Gunton 7
George Hearn 7
|
dolbinau
|
Well he isn't that behind Gunton (Whose performance I'm not even aware in even the slightest of so I don't know how to vote for him..)
And Salmone wtf in any other thread you are even worse, that is, you post one after the other bumping up a song or eliminating, at least in this case Hearn's falling is due to the opinion of at least a few of us and not one person.
|
Brock07
|
Sorry, I really like Hearn, but what really does him in for me is all the screaming. I fell in love with Len's portrayal and it's the definitive Sweeney for me. And I tend not to vote against someone that I'm not familiar with so that's why Hearn's taking the blow for me.
Len Cariou 24
Bob Gunton 7
George Hearn 6
|
Salome
|
Quilley is easily a better Todd thna Cariou. he is possibly even better than Hearn.
|
ActingDude17
|
+ Cariou
- Gunton
Len Cariou 25
Bob Gunton 6
George Hearn 6
|
dolbinau
|
| Salome wrote: | | Quilley is easily a better Todd thna Cariou. he is possibly even better than Hearn. |
I've only heard the BBC broadcast and some clips from the London documentary and I don't see why he is that special..What exactly makes him so good? I mean 'easily' better. I like it how (at least in this broadcast), he doesn't start screaming from the first line, so there is actually development by the time "Epiphany" ends.
|
STRWBRRY
|
I seriously can't believe that Hearn is in the last place...
+ Hearn
- Cariou
Len Cariou 24
George Hearn 7
Bob Gunton 6
Ha! 
|
dolbinau
|
+ Cariou
- Gunton [not that again I've heard ANYTHING from this]
Len Cariou 25
George Hearn 7
Bob Gunton 5
|
Brock07
|
Len Cariou 26
George Hearn 6
Bob Gunton 5
|
ILoveToSing2010
|
Len Cariou 27
George Hearn 6
Bob Gunton 4
+ Len Cariou
- Bob Gunton
|
ActingDude17
|
+ Cariou
- Gunton
Len Cariou 28
George Hearn 6
Bob Gunton 3
|
STRWBRRY
|
+ Hearn
- Cariou
Len Cariou 27
George Hearn 7
Bob Gunton 3
|
Brock07
|
Len Cariou 28
George Hearn 6
Bob Gunton 3
|
Jekkienumber24601
|
Len Cariou 28
George Hearn 7
Bob Gunton 2
+Hearn
-Guton
Where was The Stokes (Brain Stokes Mitchell) in this list? Or Kelsey Grammar?
|
ActingDude17
|
+ Cariou
- Gunton
Len Cariou 29
George Hearn 7
Bob Gunton 1
|
dolbinau
|
| Quote: |
Where was The Stokes (Brain Stokes Mitchell) in this list? Or Kelsey Grammar? |
Well I originally wanted those who have been recorded only since everyone would probably be aware of their performance, then Salome added some people - I suppose Dennis was alright since one of his performances was recorded via a BBC broadcast but things like Bob Gunton hardly anyone knows anything so it has become somewhat pointless in the 'lineup'. (As would have others).
|
SomeoneLikeYou
|
+ George Hearn
- Bob Gunton (He hardly uses his fancy chair)
Len Cariou 29
George Hearn 8
|
Jekkienumber24601
|
Len Cariou 28
George Hearn 9
-Len, sorry bud but you were better than Hearn before you were recorded and preserved forever with that throat infection.... But your "Benjamim Barker!!! and entire Final scene is always gonna be my favorite. Hearn does win with Epiphany and everything else. You beat Hearn in the Murder She Wrote cameos though!
+Hearn You were in the Barney movie. That takes balls!
|
ActingDude17
|
+ Cariou
- Hearn
Len Cariou 29
George Hearn 8
|
STRWBRRY
|
+ Hearn
- Cariou
Len Cariou 28
George Hearn 9
|
Jekkienumber24601
|
Len Cariou 28
George Hearn 10
+Hearn
=Len (not gonna take part in eliminating either of these fine Sweeneys)
|
STRWBRRY
|
+ Hearn
- Cariou
Len Cariou 27
George Hearn 11
|
ActingDude17
|
+ Hearn
- Cariou
Len Cariou 26
George Hearn 12
|
STRWBRRY
|
+ Hearn
- Cariou
Len Cariou 25
George Hearn 13
|
dolbinau
|
+ Cariou
- Hearn
Len Cariou 26
George Hearn 12
|
