[Singer]

I just finished watching this version, and I LOVE it! It seems so real and natural compared to the 1955 version. The way the songs flow so smoothly from the script, and the excellent performers of the actors and actressess... just... wow.
Although I'm not crazy about everything Josephine Gabriella did with Laurey, I do think she makes a wonderful Laurey and a welcome change from Shirley Jones. Shirley is lovely, but she doesn't bring that much depth to the role, in my opinion. Josephine really makes Laurey seem more like a real person.
I LOVE the performances of Hugh Jackman and Shuler Hensley as Curly and Jud. Excellent! I found Shuler's Jud really brought out the sympathetic aspects of his character. I felt so sorry for Jud, even though Laurey would be an idiot to choose him over Curly!
Ado Annie and Will and also both played very well, and I love the way evey song was included in the production. Especially the wonderful "Lonely Room". Love that song!
Anyway, does anyone else feel the same way about this production? I just think it is so much better than the 1955 film.

[Guinevere]

I watched it a couple of years ago when it was on PBS. In fact I was watching it in the middle of the night. So, maybe my memory might be a little foggy (it was one of my sleepless nights that I so often have).

I liked it. I liked it a lot. Then I saw the touring show of the same production. So, I kind of knew what to expect from that. I LOVED that show.

I probably have a sentimental thing going on with the 1955 film because this is one of the movies that I grew up watching all the time. I really like Hugh Jackman. I really liked him as Curly. Honestly? I have to choose Gordon MacRae. I have always loved his voice. I always thought he made such a cute Curly. For me, he seemed to fit the role quite well.

As for others in the Hugh Jackman cast, they were pretty good, I thought (except for Ado Annie - I can't think of her name right now). She annoyed me. When it comes to Will, I have to choose, yet again, the 1955 one. I have also always enjoyed Gene Nelson so much.

Talent for talent, I think the film wins hands down. For just a really good production of the show, I choose the Hugh Jackman production (or the one I saw).

Besides, I liked how Curly and Laurey danced for themselvs for the first time during the dream sequence in this version.

[Bellis]

I agree. This movie is wonderful, and I liked Hugh Jackman performance the best.
Even thow everyone were great. I sow this movie five times in a week.
I really liked it!

[Salome]

Josephina Gabrielle is perfectiuon as laurey. no one else has ever come close...except me

[The Duchess of Mint]

Dear Salome,

You must be a versatile actress, because you don't look like the stereotypically innocent, naiive Laurey to me.

Thanks in advance for your reply.

[Salome]

laurey isnt niave and stereotypical. thats why.Laurey and Curley are the frontier version of Shakespeare's Benedick and Beatrice.

did you see Josephina?

[filmphan821]

I agree with Salome, Josefina is the embodiment of Laurey. She IS Laurey to me and always will be, no one else has come close. And Hugh Jackman...yeah. He was amazing. Perfect for Curly in my opinion.

[tortallcit]

as many times as I've read the script, I have a hard time imagining any depth to the Laurie character, but congrats if you found some!

As far as the Hugh Jackman version, I loved it much more than the original, not to mention it was filmed much better.