[Salome]

Emmy Rossum cannot act..and lucy is a crappy role so..I think they fit eacvh other.

[Lorhen]

OMG! A crappy role????

[Salome]

its a crappy show...none of the roles are well written. plus Lucy has some of the most inane songs in the piece. And I personally know one of the actresses who played the role on broadway and she agrees LOL

[Lorhen]

OMG!!!! *faints* I love Lucy...

Are you talking about Coleen Sexton?

[Kragey]

"Christine Daaé (soprano) — A Swedish chorus girl at the Opéra Populaire, and the daughter of a prominent violinist. Although talented, she lacks focus until the Phantom takes her under his wing and teaches her to sing."

Emmy Rossum is not talented, and she would never be allowed in to the Opera Populaire. She cannot perform opera and cannot even pretend that she has the ability, so she could never take Carlotta's place, which is what the character is supposed to do: she's supposed to be so damn good she usurps the Opera Populaire's diva.

You can sing opera and still sound innocent, and there are many soprano parts in actual opera that require innocence. Other actresses have managed the part of Christine just fine, so why give it to a singer who has to have the music changed for her? Why not give the part to somebody who could actually handle the role?

And her voice doesn't fit Lucy at all. I'll give you Emma, but that's a stretch.

[ChorusKidx3]

Oh I love this movie so much! I first watched it on youtube. I loved it so much. Hasslehoff, I think did a fantabulous job. I love that musical so much and I think at our school we're doing it next year. SQUEE!

[Brock07]

[ChorusKidx3]

[jcstar]

I still want Paul Stanley to be in the film. He has the chops for J&H.

Andy.

[Lorhen]

isn't he a bit old...????


anyway... what do you think of the Sweeney Todd Movie's Johanna???

Jayne Wisener....???

she's so pretty, sweet, a wonderful voice... and young!

she was born in 1987.

I think she would be cute...

[jcstar]