Archive for Musicals.Net Musicals.Net |
| Luc |
O/T [kinda] - Harry Potter & Secret Garden Similarities!Guys... it can't only be me that notices it - just one line of the book, but still.I have noticed it since about HP3 (Prisoner of Azkaban), but I actually laughed out loud in HP7 about how close it is. Has anyone else noticed that Harry has LILY'S EYES?! In The Deathly Hallows, there is actually a line that says "He has her eyes." Although Lily Potter's eyes are green as opposed to hazel, I still think it's pretty rad. Well, sorry for sounding all fangirly, but I just think it's really weird. |
||||||
| pish123c |
Wait
Lily is Harrys mom... And Lily happens to be the name of the main character in "The Secret Garden" And Harry has Lily's (his mother) eyes. And that brings us back to TSG? It's like the 6 degrees of Kevin Bacon or whatever. 
|
||||||
| Pannic |
When I was reading Deathly Hallows I could just see Snape singing some version of "Lily's Eyes." | ||||||
| kozafluitmusique |
Haha. I thought of the "Lily's Eyes" too when I was reading the book.
and the Snape thing a little, too ;D |
||||||
| ConverseSneaker |
Hehehe....Snape and James can sing Lily's eyes. 
|
||||||
| shakalakababy |
yeah i've though of that too. I think there's even a video somewhere on youtube with pictures daniel radcliffe and lilys eyes | ||||||
| LittleGavroche |
I thought I was the only one who noticed that
|
||||||
| windbelle |
Seems most people who are familiar with The Secret Garden have noticed the same thing. It almost made me wonder if JKR was a fan of the musical.
|
||||||
| kozafluitmusique |
I told my mom that yesterday and she was just shook her head and sighed. | ||||||
| Jennifer Lynn |
Ha. Thanks to that song, I called it on Snape being in love with Lily from Book One!
(Although I was pleasantly surprised by the way it was ultimately presented. To have Snape and Lily be friends, and actually have Snape's own actions torpedo any chance he had with her...that's more interesting than having Snape pine away for some girl he had on a pedestal only to have her "stolen" by James Potter. And Snape always knew, deep inside, that it was his OWN fault things went south...his guilt over that must have only increased his resentment of James and Harry.) |
||||||
| rcs |
I have always thought that naming Harry's mother "Lily" (and giving him her eyes) was a deliberate nod to The Secret Garden. J. K. Rowling is well versed in English literature, so she has undoubtably read the book. Also, there are other parallels (main character loses parents unexpectedly, sent to live with uncle and cousin) that lead me to believe that this is more than a coincidence.
And I love the Snape and James idea. Any filkers want to take it up? I've seen one "Lily's Eyes" filk on the internet already, but it wasn't about Snape (it was written before Book 7 came out).[/i] |
||||||
| jetblack_diva |
I like that  thats amazing!
|
||||||
| Snow_White |
Wow I thought I was the only one to muse over that teehee
I always pictured James and Snape singing something like, 'He has my Lily's emerald eyes!' Man...someone should write that... |
||||||
| *BroadwayLights* |
I was in this show when the book came out, and when I read it I couldn't help but laugh 
|
||||||
| jetblack_diva |
Someone needs to tell the guys that make potter puppet pals!!!!!!!!! that would be hilarious!!!!!!! Omg does ne one know them That would be so funny! Snape and James are holding out "... MY LILY'S... EYES" "naked time" and dumbledore pops up!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! o wow!
|
||||||
| Oli-Ol |
I actually love you!
I've never noticed this before but I think you are completely right!
|
||||||
| KristinT |
It's vaguely possible that Rowling could have been thinking of the musical (it did come out in the late 80s after all, so has been around for ages) but remember in the book (and movies, including the awesome one with Maggie Smith) her name is actually Lilias. I don't blame the musical's writers for changing it as 'Lilias' would probably scan awkwardly in melodies and it meant that they would carry on the flower symbolism in calling her sister Rose (Mary's mother is unnamed in the book, I think). | ||||||
| jetblack_diva |
wait what who do you love??? |
||||||
| Oli-Ol |
Would it upset you that much?
I don't know, really. I may have been refering to whoever began the post or... someone random. Can't remember I'm afraid! Also- I'm in SG now and none of the people who are doing it with me think that HP has anything to do with it. Sheer coincidence and people reading too much into it in their opinion. |
||||||
| Sphynx |
This is actually how my friend got me into the song She was like "It's such a SNAPE song!"
That won me over pretty quickly. Really, it does make you wonder, although I doubt there is any connection. |
||||||
| sarahex |
How much do you think harry potter theme park tickets will cost?
Disneyland tickets are around $50-75 per adult or child. Do you think the ticket prices for the Harry Potter Park will be exorbitant? I don't know about you but my boys are already planning their vacation in two years. ________________ keyword research ~ keyword tool ~ keyword tracking ~ affiliate elite |
||||||
| Inspector Javert |
Someone needs to make a music video
|
||||||
| jetblack_diva |
No it wouldn't bother me at all! I was just hoping someone actually thought me saying that was funny! sometimes i'm the only one to laugh at what i say 
|
||||||
| Oli-Ol |
^^ I do that all the time! I think I'm being really witty and clever and everyone else just looks at me like:
'No.' But I think in this instance you were being funny
|