Anno_Domini
|
M.T. Composer Elimination Game!This is a follow-up to a poll that was posted, asking people who their fav musical theatre composer was. However, it was smewhat lacking in options. So, for your consideration, here's:
THE MUSICAL THEATRE COMPOSER ELIMINATION SHOWDOWN SHOWDOWNSHOWDOWN!!!
The Rules: add 1 point each to your 2 favorite composers, subtract 1 point each from your 2 least favorites. No adding or subtracting 2 from the same composer. They all begin with 5 points. Let's get it on!
Andrew "20 Freakin' Years" Lloyd Webber - 5
Stephen "Seen-It-All" Sondheim - 5
Stephen "I-Know-About-Popular" Schwartz - 5
John "All-That-(and more)-Jazz" Kander - 5
Jonathan "One-Hit-Glory" Larson - 5
Fred "If-Ever-We-Did-Leave-Him" Loewe - 5
Jason "Schmuel" Robert Brown - 6 (+)
Lawrence "OHMIGOD" O'Keefe - 6 (+)
"Some Enchanted" Richard Rodgers - 4 (-)
Adam "The Light" Guetel - 4 (-)
David "Yowza" Yazbek - 5
Mel "Words-Fail-Me" Brooks - 5
Jeanine "Don't-Forget-About-the-Girl" Tesori - 5
Cole "De-Loveable" Porter
Leonard "Achoo-Gezhunteit-Thanks" Bernstein - 5
"Favourite Son" Cy Coleman - 5
"Rocketman" Elton John - 5
"There-Once-Was-a-Man" Richard Adler - 5
Frank "The Moment" Wildhorn - 5
Jule "Let Him Entertain You" Styne - 5
Frank "Succeeded-Without-Really-Trying" Loesser - 5
Alan "Mickey Mouse" Menken - 5
Claude-Michel "Mr. Saigon" Schonberg - 5
Stephen "New Music" Flaherty - 5
Irving "The Ritz" Berlin - 5
|
Salome
|
Stephen "Seen-It-All" Sondheim - 7
Cole "De-Loveable" Porter -6
John "All-That-(and more)-Jazz" Kander - 5
Jonathan "One-Hit-Glory" Larson - 5
Fred "If-Ever-We-Did-Leave-Him" Loewe - 5
Jason "Schmuel" Robert Brown - 6 (+)
Lawrence "OHMIGOD" O'Keefe - 6 (+)
"Some Enchanted" Richard Rodgers - 4 (-)
Adam "The Light" Guetel - 4 (-)
David "Yowza" Yazbek - 5
Mel "Words-Fail-Me" Brooks - 5
Jeanine "Don't-Forget-About-the-Girl" Tesori - 5
Leonard "Achoo-Gezhunteit-Thanks" Bernstein - 5
"Favourite Son" Cy Coleman - 5
"Rocketman" Elton John - 5
"There-Once-Was-a-Man" Richard Adler - 5
Frank "The Moment" Wildhorn - 5
Jule "Let Him Entertain You" Styne - 5
Frank "Succeeded-Without-Really-Trying" Loesser - 5
Alan "Mickey Mouse" Menken - 5
Stephen "New Music" Flaherty - 5
Irving "The Ritz" Berlin - 5
Andrew "20 Freakin' Years" Lloyd Webber - 4
Stephen "I-Know-About-Popular" Schwartz - 4
_________________
|
Kiwi
|
Andrew "20 Freakin' Years" Lloyd Webber - 4 (-)
Stephen "Seen-It-All" Sondheim - 6 (+)
Stephen "I-Know-About-Popular" Schwartz - 5
John "All-That-(and more)-Jazz" Kander - 5
Jonathan "One-Hit-Glory" Larson - 5
Fred "If-Ever-We-Did-Leave-Him" Loewe - 5
Jason "Schmuel" Robert Brown - 6
Lawrence "OHMIGOD" O'Keefe - 6
"Some Enchanted" Richard Rodgers - 3 (-)
Adam "The Light" Guetel - 5 (+)
David "Yowza" Yazbek - 5
Mel "Words-Fail-Me" Brooks - 5
Jeanine "Don't-Forget-About-the-Girl" Tesori - 5
Cole "De-Loveable" Porter
Leonard "Achoo-Gezhunteit-Thanks" Bernstein - 5
"Favourite Son" Cy Coleman - 5
"Rocketman" Elton John - 5
"There-Once-Was-a-Man" Richard Adler - 5
Frank "The Moment" Wildhorn - 5
Jule "Let Him Entertain You" Styne - 5
Frank "Succeeded-Without-Really-Trying" Loesser - 5
Alan "Mickey Mouse" Menken - 5
Stephen "New Music" Flaherty - 5
Irving "The Ritz" Berlin - 5
|
Anno_Domini
|
REMINDER:
You can't add or subtract 2 points FROM THE SAME COMPOSER!!!
|
Kiwi
|
If you're referring to me, I put mine in just after Salome, basing it off of your original post.
|
Anno_Domini
|
I'm referring to Salome, who added 2 for Sondheim
So, taking into account Salome's choices:
Andrew "20 Freakin' Years" Lloyd Webber - 3
Stephen "Seen-It-All" Sondheim - 7
Stephen "I-Know-About-Popular" Schwartz - 4
John "All-That-(and more)-Jazz" Kander - 5
Jonathan "One-Hit-Glory" Larson - 5
Fred "If-Ever-We-Did-Leave-Him" Loewe - 5
Jason "Schmuel" Robert Brown - 6
Lawrence "OHMIGOD" O'Keefe - 6
"Some Enchanted" Richard Rodgers - 3
Adam "The Light" Guetel - 5
David "Yowza" Yazbek - 5
Mel "Words-Fail-Me" Brooks - 5
Jeanine "Don't-Forget-About-the-Girl" Tesori - 5
Cole "De-Loveable" Porter - 6
Leonard "Achoo-Gezhunteit-Thanks" Bernstein - 5
"Favourite Son" Cy Coleman - 5
"Rocketman" Elton John - 5
"There-Once-Was-a-Man" Richard Adler - 5
Frank "The Moment" Wildhorn - 5
Jule "Let Him Entertain You" Styne - 5
Frank "Succeeded-Without-Really-Trying" Loesser - 5
Alan "Mickey Mouse" Menken - 5
Stephen "New Music" Flaherty - 5
Irving "The Ritz" Berlin - 5
|
jax1491
|
Andrew "20 Freakin' Years" Lloyd Webber - 3
Stephen "Seen-It-All" Sondheim - 8 (+)
Stephen "I-Know-About-Popular" Schwartz - 3 (-)
John "All-That-(and more)-Jazz" Kander - 5
Jonathan "One-Hit-Glory" Larson - 5
Fred "If-Ever-We-Did-Leave-Him" Loewe - 5
Jason "Schmuel" Robert Brown - 6
Lawrence "OHMIGOD" O'Keefe - 6
"Some Enchanted" Richard Rodgers - 3
Adam "The Light" Guetel - 5
David "Yowza" Yazbek - 5
Mel "Words-Fail-Me" Brooks - 5
Jeanine "Don't-Forget-About-the-Girl" Tesori - 5
Cole "De-Loveable" Porter - 7 (+)
Leonard "Achoo-Gezhunteit-Thanks" Bernstein - 5
"Favourite Son" Cy Coleman - 5
"Rocketman" Elton John - 5
"There-Once-Was-a-Man" Richard Adler - 5
Frank "The Moment" Wildhorn - 5
Jule "Let Him Entertain You" Styne - 5
Frank "Succeeded-Without-Really-Trying" Loesser - 5
Alan "Mickey Mouse" Menken - 4 (-)
Stephen "New Music" Flaherty - 5
Irving "The Ritz" Berlin - 5
|
Luc
|
Did you think of all these names?! They're awesome! 
Andrew "20 Freakin' Years" Lloyd Webber - 2
Stephen "Seen-It-All" Sondheim - 8 (+)
Stephen "I-Know-About-Popular" Schwartz - 4 (-)
John "All-That-(and more)-Jazz" Kander - 5
Jonathan "One-Hit-Glory" Larson - 5
Fred "If-Ever-We-Did-Leave-Him" Loewe - 5
Jason "Schmuel" Robert Brown - 6
Lawrence "OHMIGOD" O'Keefe - 7
"Some Enchanted" Richard Rodgers - 3
Adam "The Light" Guetel - 5
David "Yowza" Yazbek - 5
Mel "Words-Fail-Me" Brooks - 5
Jeanine "Don't-Forget-About-the-Girl" Tesori - 5
Cole "De-Loveable" Porter - 7 (+)
Leonard "Achoo-Gezhunteit-Thanks" Bernstein - 5
"Favourite Son" Cy Coleman - 5
"Rocketman" Elton John - 5
"There-Once-Was-a-Man" Richard Adler - 5
Frank "The Moment" Wildhorn - 5
Jule "Let Him Entertain You" Styne - 5
Frank "Succeeded-Without-Really-Trying" Loesser - 5
Alan "Mickey Mouse" Menken - 5 (-)
Stephen "New Music" Flaherty - 5
Irving "The Ritz" Berlin - 5
|
wicked_boy
|
Andrew "20 Freakin' Years" Lloyd Webber - 3 (+)
Stephen "Seen-It-All" Sondheim - 8
Stephen "I-Know-About-Popular" Schwartz - 4
John "All-That-(and more)-Jazz" Kander - 5
Jonathan "One-Hit-Glory" Larson - 5
Fred "If-Ever-We-Did-Leave-Him" Loewe - 5 (-)
Jason "Schmuel" Robert Brown - 6
Lawrence "OHMIGOD" O'Keefe - 7
"Some Enchanted" Richard Rodgers - 3
Adam "The Light" Guetel - 5
David "Yowza" Yazbek - 5
Mel "Words-Fail-Me" Brooks - 5
Jeanine "Don't-Forget-About-the-Girl" Tesori - 5
Cole "De-Loveable" Porter - 7
Leonard "Achoo-Gezhunteit-Thanks" Bernstein - 5
"Favourite Son" Cy Coleman - 5
"Rocketman" Elton John - 5
"There-Once-Was-a-Man" Richard Adler - 5
Frank "The Moment" Wildhorn - 5
Jule "Let Him Entertain You" Styne - 5
Frank "Succeeded-Without-Really-Trying" Loesser - 4 (-)
Alan "Mickey Mouse" Menken - 6 (+)
Stephen "New Music" Flaherty - 5
Irving "The Ritz" Berlin - 5
I wonder who will win. 
|
kakoforever
|
I feel like this has been done before, and either people start arguing and the game dies, or the same person always wins. 
|
Mungojerrie_rt
|
You forgot Pete Townsend.
Andrew "20 Freakin' Years" Lloyd Webber - 4 (+)
Stephen "Seen-It-All" Sondheim - 8
Stephen "I-Know-About-Popular" Schwartz - 4
John "All-That-(and more)-Jazz" Kander - 6 (+)
Jonathan "One-Hit-Glory" Larson - 5
Fred "If-Ever-We-Did-Leave-Him" Loewe - 4 (-)
Jason "Schmuel" Robert Brown - 6
Lawrence "OHMIGOD" O'Keefe - 7
"Some Enchanted" Richard Rodgers - 2 (-)
Adam "The Light" Guetel - 5
David "Yowza" Yazbek - 5
Mel "Words-Fail-Me" Brooks - 5
Jeanine "Don't-Forget-About-the-Girl" Tesori - 5
Cole "De-Loveable" Porter - 7
Leonard "Achoo-Gezhunteit-Thanks" Bernstein - 5
"Favourite Son" Cy Coleman - 5
"Rocketman" Elton John - 5
"There-Once-Was-a-Man" Richard Adler - 5
Frank "The Moment" Wildhorn - 5
Jule "Let Him Entertain You" Styne - 5
Frank "Succeeded-Without-Really-Trying" Loesser - 4
Alan "Mickey Mouse" Menken - 6
Stephen "New Music" Flaherty - 5
Irving "The Ritz" Berlin - 5
|
Pannic
|
| Mungojerrie_rt wrote: | | You forgot Pete Townsend. |
He's only got three musicals staged, and only one of which is particularly relevent. And was arguably better as an album.
|
Mungojerrie_rt
|
Mel Brooks only has two but he was included. How many has Elton John done?
|
Anno_Domini
|
| Quote: | | Did you think of all these names?! They're awesome! |
Indeed I did, and thank you 
| Quote: | | Mel Brooks only has two but he was included. How many has Elton John done? |
Mel Brooks, as well as Jonathan Larson, were included due to the unbridled popularity of their shows (The Producers and Rent respectively)
And Sir Elton has done The Lion King, Aida, Lestat (unfortunately), and Billy Elliot. And for all I know, he may have done more.
As for Pete "CSI Theme Song" Townshend, I'm only aware of one show that he's down: Tommy
|
Pannic
|
Mel Brooks has three, actually. You forgot "All American." I think "Robin Hood Men in Tights" was unsuccessfully produced on stage, as well.
As for Petey, his masterpiece, Quadrophenia, has yet to hit stage, and due to the nature of the album, I don't quite see how it's possible to be faithfully staged outside of concert.
|
Yip1982
|
I would like to add one point for Rodgers, so his score will be 4. I think his style is more consistent, and there's something so comforting and classic about his musicals. I know there are some things I don't feel comfortable about, but still I would do it for the sake of SOM and K&I. However, while I feel tempted to add a point for Lloyd-Webber, I think I'd rather not do it as I've found out that I tend to like only one score of his, Cats.
|
wicked_diva
|
Where is Finn?
|
Salome
|
if you want to tlak about forgetting peopel..Noel Coward whow wrote 9 musicals and is called 'The Master".
|
Anno_Domini
|
William "What-More-Can-We-Say" Finn I did forget, yes.
As for Noel Coward, I know he wrote songs in his some of his plays, but I've never really thought of him to be a musical theatre composer. What's his most famous musical?
So I shall throw Finn into the mix, but not Mr. Coward as of yet.
(geez, make a list of 25 composers and people still complain
Andrew "20 Freakin' Years" Lloyd Webber - 4 (+)
Stephen "Seen-It-All" Sondheim - 8
Stephen "I-Know-About-Popular" Schwartz - 4
John "All-That-(and more)-Jazz" Kander - 6 (+)
Jonathan "One-Hit-Glory" Larson - 5
Fred "If-Ever-We-Did-Leave-Him" Loewe - 4 (-)
Jason "Schmuel" Robert Brown - 6
Lawrence "OHMIGOD" O'Keefe - 7
"Some Enchanted" Richard Rodgers - 2 (-)
Adam "The Light" Guetel - 5
David "Yowza" Yazbek - 5
Mel "Words-Fail-Me" Brooks - 5
Jeanine "Don't-Forget-About-the-Girl" Tesori - 5
Cole "De-Loveable" Porter - 7
Leonard "Achoo-Gezhunteit-Thanks" Bernstein - 5
"Favourite Son" Cy Coleman - 5
"Rocketman" Elton John - 5
"There-Once-Was-a-Man" Richard Adler - 5
Frank "The Moment" Wildhorn - 5
Jule "Let Him Entertain You" Styne - 5
William "What-More-Can-We-Say" Finn - 5
Frank "Succeeded-Without-Really-Trying" Loesser - 4
Alan "Mickey Mouse" Menken - 6
Stephen "New Music" Flaherty - 5
Irving "The Ritz" Berlin - 5
|
Salome
|
Cowards big musicals...
Bittersweet (filmed twice)
The Girl Who Came To Supper
Sail Away
Conversation Piece
This Year of Grace
Red Peppers
Pacific 1870
I opnly complained because Coward is one of the 5 greats
trivia: Sandy Wilson';s' musical "The boyfriend" was a parody of Coward style shows of the 30s.
|
Salome
|
Andrew "20 Freakin' Years" Lloyd Webber - 3 -
Stephen "Seen-It-All" Sondheim - 9 +
Stephen "I-Know-About-Popular" Schwartz - 4
John "All-That-(and more)-Jazz" Kander - 6
Jonathan "One-Hit-Glory" Larson - 5
Fred "If-Ever-We-Did-Leave-Him" Loewe - 4
Jason "Schmuel" Robert Brown - 6
Lawrence "OHMIGOD" O'Keefe - 7
"Some Enchanted" Richard Rodgers - 2
Adam "The Light" Guetel - 5
David "Yowza" Yazbek - 5
Mel "Words-Fail-Me" Brooks - 5
Jeanine "Don't-Forget-About-the-Girl" Tesori - 5
Cole "De-Loveable" Porter - 8 +
Leonard "Achoo-Gezhunteit-Thanks" Bernstein - 5
"Favourite Son" Cy Coleman - 5
"Rocketman" Elton John - 5
"There-Once-Was-a-Man" Richard Adler - 5
Frank "The Moment" Wildhorn - 4 -
Jule "Let Him Entertain You" Styne - 5
William "What-More-Can-We-Say" Finn - 5
Frank "Succeeded-Without-Really-Trying" Loesser - 4
Alan "Mickey Mouse" Menken - 6
Stephen "New Music" Flaherty - 5
Irving "The Ritz" Berlin - 5
|
Matthew
|
lol 2 this thread
|
Mungojerrie_rt
|
Andrew "20 Freakin' Years" Lloyd Webber - 4 (+)
Stephen "Seen-It-All" Sondheim - 9
Stephen "I-Know-About-Popular" Schwartz - 4
John "All-That-(and more)-Jazz" Kander - 6
Jonathan "One-Hit-Glory" Larson - 5
Fred "If-Ever-We-Did-Leave-Him" Loewe - 4
Jason "Schmuel" Robert Brown - 6
Lawrence "OHMIGOD" O'Keefe - 7
"Some Enchanted" Richard Rodgers - 1 (-)
Adam "The Light" Guetel - 5
David "Yowza" Yazbek - 5
Mel "Words-Fail-Me" Brooks - 6 (+)
Jeanine "Don't-Forget-About-the-Girl" Tesori - 5
Cole "De-Loveable" Porter - 8
Leonard "Achoo-Gezhunteit-Thanks" Bernstein - 5
"Favourite Son" Cy Coleman - 5
"Rocketman" Elton John - 5
"There-Once-Was-a-Man" Richard Adler - 5
Frank "The Moment" Wildhorn - 4 -
Jule "Let Him Entertain You" Styne - 5
William "What-More-Can-We-Say" Finn - 5
Frank "Succeeded-Without-Really-Trying" Loesser - 4
Alan "Mickey Mouse" Menken - 6
Stephen "New Music" Flaherty - 5
Irving "The Ritz" Berlin - 4 (-)
|
Salome
|
Andrew "20 Freakin' Years" Lloyd Webber - 3 -
Stephen "Seen-It-All" Sondheim - 10 +
Stephen "I-Know-About-Popular" Schwartz - 3 -
John "All-That-(and more)-Jazz" Kander - 6
Jonathan "One-Hit-Glory" Larson - 5
Fred "If-Ever-We-Did-Leave-Him" Loewe - 5 +
Jason "Schmuel" Robert Brown - 6
Lawrence "OHMIGOD" O'Keefe - 7
"Some Enchanted" Richard Rodgers - 1
Adam "The Light" Guetel - 5
David "Yowza" Yazbek - 5
Mel "Words-Fail-Me" Brooks - 6
Jeanine "Don't-Forget-About-the-Girl" Tesori - 5
Cole "De-Loveable" Porter - 8
Leonard "Achoo-Gezhunteit-Thanks" Bernstein - 5
"Favourite Son" Cy Coleman - 5
"Rocketman" Elton John - 5
"There-Once-Was-a-Man" Richard Adler - 5
Frank "The Moment" Wildhorn - 4 -
Jule "Let Him Entertain You" Styne - 5
William "What-More-Can-We-Say" Finn - 5
Frank "Succeeded-Without-Really-Trying" Loesser - 4
Alan "Mickey Mouse" Menken - 6
Stephen "New Music" Flaherty - 5
Irving "The Ritz" Berlin - 4
|
Pannic
|
Explain to me how the hell Richard Rodgers only has one?
|
Yip1982
|
Lloyd Webber - 3 -
Sondheim - 10 +
Schwartz - 3 -
Kander - 6
Larson - 5
Loewe - 5 +
JRB - 6
O'Keefe - 7
Rodgers - 2 +
Guetel - 5
Yazbek - 5
Brooks - 6
Tesori - 5
Porter - 8
Bernstein - 5
Coleman - 5
Elton John - 5
Richard Adler - 5
Wildhorn - 4 -
Styne - 5
Finn - 5
Loesser - 4
Menken - 6
Flaherty - 5
Berlin - 4
|
Salome
|
Lloyd Webber - 2 -
Sondheim - 10
Schwartz - 3 -
Kander - 6
Larson - 5
Loewe - 5
JRB - 6
O'Keefe - 7
Rodgers - 2
Guetel - 5
Yazbek - 5
Brooks - 6
Tesori - 5
Porter - 9 +
Bernstein - 5
Coleman - 5
Elton John - 5
Richard Adler - 5
Wildhorn - 3 -
Styne - 5
Finn - 5
Loesser - 4
Menken - 6
Flaherty - 5
Berlin - 5 +
|
Mungojerrie_rt
|
Lloyd Webber - 3 +
Sondheim - 10
Schwartz - 3
Kander - 6
Larson - 6 +
Loewe - 5
JRB - 6
O'Keefe - 7
Rodgers - 1 -
Guetel - 5
Yazbek - 5
Brooks - 6
Tesori - 5
Porter - 8 -
Bernstein - 5
Coleman - 5
Elton John - 5
Richard Adler - 5
Wildhorn - 3
Styne - 5
Finn - 5
Loesser - 4
Menken - 6
Flaherty - 5
Berlin - 5
|
Salome
|
Lloyd Webber - 2-
Sondheim - 10
Schwartz - 2 -
Kander - 6
Larson - 6
Loewe - 6 +
JRB - 6
O'Keefe - 7
Rodgers - 1
Guetel - 5
Yazbek - 5
Brooks - 6
Tesori - 5
Porter - 9 +
Bernstein - 5
Coleman - 5
Elton John - 5
Richard Adler - 5
Wildhorn - 3
Styne - 5
Finn - 5
Loesser - 4
Menken - 6
Flaherty - 5
Berlin - 5
|
actor
|
+ Sondheim
+ Porter
- Lloyd Webber
- Schwartz
Sondheim - 11
Porter - 10
O'Keefe - 7
Kander - 6
Larson - 6
Loewe - 6
JRB - 6
Menken - 6
Brooks - 6
Guetel - 5
Yazbek - 5
Tesori - 5
Bernstein - 5
Coleman - 5
Tesori - 5
Elton John - 5
Richard Adler - 5
Styne - 5
Finn - 5
Flaherty - 5
Berlin - 5
Loesser - 4
Wildhorn - 3
Schwartz - 1
Lloyd Webber - 1
Rodgers - 1
|
Salome
|
Sondheim - 11
Porter - 11
Loewe - 7
O'Keefe - 7
Kander - 6
Larson - 6
JRB - 6
Menken - 6
Brooks - 6
Guetel - 5
Yazbek - 5
Tesori - 5
Bernstein - 5
Coleman - 5
Tesori - 5
Elton John - 5
Richard Adler - 5
Styne - 5
Finn - 5
Flaherty - 5
Berlin - 5
Loesser - 4
Wildhorn - 3
Rodgers - 1
- webber BYE!
-Schwartz - BYE!
+ Porter
+ Loewe
|
Mungojerrie_rt
|
Sondheim - 10 (-)
Porter - 11
Loewe - 7
O'Keefe - 7
Kander - 6
Larson - 6
JRB - 6
Menken - 7 (+)
Brooks - 7 (+)
Guetel - 5
Yazbek - 5
Tesori - 5
Bernstein - 5
Coleman - 5
Tesori - 5
Elton John - 5
Richard Adler - 5
Styne - 5
Finn - 5
Flaherty - 5
Berlin - 5
Loesser - 4
Wildhorn - 3
Rodgers - 0 (- Bye bye)
|
Salome
|
Sondheim - 11 +
Porter - 11
Loewe - 8 +
O'Keefe - 7
Kander - 6
Larson - 6
JRB - 6
Menken - 6 -
Brooks - 7
Guetel - 4 -
Yazbek - 5
Tesori - 5
Bernstein - 5
Coleman - 5
Tesori - 5
Elton John - 5
Richard Adler - 5
Styne - 5
Finn - 5
Flaherty - 5
Berlin - 5
Loesser - 4
Wildhorn - 2 -
|
wicked_boy
|
Damn, will be a close tie!
|
Salome
|
| wicked_boy wrote: | | Damn, will be a close tie! |
post yours damn it lol
|
wicked_boy
|
Here you go...
Sondheim - 11 +
Porter - 11
Loewe - 8 +
O'Keefe - 7
Kander - 5 (-)
Larson - 6
JRB - 6
Menken - 7 (+)
Brooks - 7
Guetel - 3 (-)
Yazbek - 5
Tesori - 5
Bernstein - 5
Coleman - 5
Tesori - 5
Elton John - 6 (+)
Richard Adler - 5
Styne - 5
Finn - 5
Flaherty - 5
Berlin - 5
Loesser - 4
Wildhorn - 2
|
Salome
|
Sondheim - 12 +
Porter - 12 +
Loewe - 8
O'Keefe - 7
Kander - 4 -
Larson - 6
JRB - 6
Menken - 7
Brooks - 7
Guetel - 3
Yazbek - 5
Tesori - 5
Bernstein - 5
Coleman - 5
Tesori - 5
Elton John - 6
Richard Adler - 5
Styne - 5
Finn - 5
Flaherty - 5
Berlin - 5
Loesser - 4
Wildhorn - 1 -
|
wicked_boy
|
Sondheim - 11 (-)
Porter - 12 +
Loewe - 8
O'Keefe - 8 (+)
Kander - 4 -
Larson - 7 (+)
JRB - 6
Menken - 7
Brooks - 7
Guetel - 3
Yazbek - 5
Tesori - 5
Bernstein - 5
Coleman - 5
Tesori - 5
Elton John - 6
Richard Adler - 5
Styne - 5
Finn - 5
Flaherty - 5
Berlin - 5
Loesser - 4
Wildhorn - 0 (-) (Toodle-pip.)
|
Salome
|
Sondheim - 12 +
Porter - 12
Loewe - 8
O'Keefe - 7 -
Kander - 4
Larson - 7
JRB - 6
Menken - 7
Brooks - 7
Guettel - 2 -
Yazbek - 5
Tesori - 5
Bernstein - 5
Coleman - 5
Tesori - 5
Elton John - 6
Richard Adler - 5
Styne - 5
Finn - 5
Flaherty - 5
Berlin - 6 +
Loesser - 4
|
wicked_boy
|
Sondheim - 12
Porter - 12
Loewe - 8
O'Keefe - 7
Kander - 4
Larson - 7
JRB - 6
Menken - 8 (+)
Brooks - 8 (+)
Guettel - 2
Yazbek - 5
Tesori - 5
Bernstein - 5
Coleman - 5
Tesori - 4 (-)
Elton John - 6
Richard Adler - 5
Styne - 4 (-)
Finn - 5
Flaherty - 5
Berlin - 6
Loesser - 4
|
Salome
|
Sondheim - 12
Porter - 12
Loewe - 8
O'Keefe - 7
Kander - 5 +
Larson - 7
JRB - 6
Menken - 8
Brooks - 8
Guettel - 1 -
Yazbek - 5
Tesori - 5
Bernstein - 5
Coleman - 5
Tesori - 4
Elton John - 6
Richard Adler - 5
Styne - 5 +
Finn - 3 -
Flaherty - 5
Berlin - 6
Loesser - 4
|
wicked_boy
|
My last one for the day...
Sondheim - 13 (+)
Porter - 12
Loewe - 8
O'Keefe - 7
Kander - 5
Larson - 7
JRB - 6
Menken - 9 (+)
Brooks - 8
Guettel - 0 (-) (Fare well.)
Yazbek - 5
Tesori - 5
Bernstein - 5
Coleman - 5
Tesori - 4
Elton John - 6
Richard Adler - 5
Styne - 4 (-)
Finn - 3
Flaherty - 5
Berlin - 6
Loesser - 4
|
Salome
|
Sondheim - 13
Porter - 13 +
Loewe - 8
O'Keefe - 7
Kander - 5
Larson - 7
JRB - 6
Menken - 9
Brooks - 8
Yazbek - 5
Tesori - 5
Bernstein - 5
Coleman - 5
Tesori - 3 -
Elton John - 4 -
Richard Adler - 5
Styne - 5 +
Finn - 3
Flaherty - 5
Berlin - 6
Loesser - 4
|
Anno_Domini
|
Aww, you people got rid of all the nicknames? I worked a long time coming up with all of those 
Well, at least let's keep their first names in play
Stephen Sondheim - 13
Cole Porter - 12 (-)
Alan Menken - 9
Mel Brooks - 8
Lawrence O'Keefe - 8 (+)
Frederick Loewe - 7 (-)
Jonathan Larson - 7
Jason Robert Brown - 6
Irving Berlin - 6
John Kander - 5
Claude-Michel Schonberg - 5
David Yazbek - 5
Leonard Bernstein - 5
Cy Coleman - 5
Stephen Flaherty - 5
Elton John - 5 (+)
Richard Adler - 5
Jule Styne - 5
Frank Loesser - 4
William Finn - 3
Jeanine Tesori - 3
Alright, we've got Stephen "Seen-It-All" Sondheim leading the pack, with Cole "De-Loveable" Porter right on his tail. However, the magic of Disney seems to be at work here, as Alan "Mickey Mouse" Menken is quickly closing the gap, with Mel "Words-Fail-Me" Brooks and Larry "OHMIGOD" O'Keefe not far behind.
Joining the pack is Claude-Michel "Less-Miserable" Schonberg
|
Salome
|
I still think Noel "mad about the Boy" Coward should be included.
|
Salome
|
Stephen Sondheim - 13
Cole Porter - 13 +
Alan Menken - 9
Frederick Loewe - 8 +
Mel Brooks - 8
Lawrence O'Keefe - 7-
Jonathan Larson - 7
Jason Robert Brown - 6
Irving Berlin - 6
John Kander - 5
Claude-Michel Schonberg - 5
David Yazbek - 5
Leonard Bernstein - 5
Cy Coleman - 5
Stephen Flaherty - 5
Elton John - 4 -
Richard Adler - 5
Jule Styne - 5
Frank Loesser - 4
William Finn - 3
Jeanine Tesori - 3
|
Anno_Domini
|
Fair enough
Stephen Sondheim - 13
Cole Porter - 12 (-)
Alan Menken - 9
Mel Brooks - 8
Lawrence O'Keefe - 8 (+)
Frederick Loewe - 7 (-)
Jonathan Larson - 7
Jason Robert Brown - 6
Irving Berlin - 6
Noel Coward - 5
John Kander - 5
Claude-Michel Schonberg - 5
David Yazbek - 5
Leonard Bernstein - 5
Cy Coleman - 5
Stephen Flaherty - 5
Elton John - 5 (+)
Richard Adler - 5
Jule Styne - 5
Frank Loesser - 4
William Finn - 3
Jeanine Tesori - 3
|
Salome
|
Stephen Sondheim - 13
Cole Porter - 13 +
Alan Menken - 9
Mel Brooks - 8
Lawrence O'Keefe - 7 -
Frederick Loewe - 7
Jonathan Larson - 7
Jason Robert Brown - 6
Irving Berlin - 6
Noel Coward - 6 +
John Kander - 5
Claude-Michel Schonberg - 5
David Yazbek - 5
Leonard Bernstein - 5
Cy Coleman - 5
Stephen Flaherty - 5
Elton John - 3 -
Richard Adler - 5
Jule Styne - 5
Frank Loesser - 4
William Finn - 3
Jeanine Tesori - 3
|
Buff Daddy
|
Stephen Sondheim - 13
Cole Porter - 14 +
Alan Menken - 9
Mel Brooks - 8
Lawrence O'Keefe - 7
Frederick Loewe - 7
Jonathan Larson - 7
Jason Robert Brown - 6
Irving Berlin - 6
Noel Coward - 6 +
John Kander - 5
Claude-Michel Schonberg - 5
David Yazbek - 5
Leonard Bernstein - 5
Cy Coleman - 5
Stephen Flaherty - 5
Elton John - 3 -
Richard Adler - 5
Jule Styne - 5
Frank Loesser - 4
Jeanine Tesori - 3
William Finn - 2 -
|
Salome
|
Stephen Sondheim - 13
Cole Porter - 14
Alan Menken - 9
Mel Brooks - 8
Lawrence O'Keefe - 6 -
Frederick Loewe - 8 +
Jonathan Larson - 7
Jason Robert Brown - 6
Irving Berlin - 6
Noel Coward - 7 +
John Kander - 5
Claude-Michel Schonberg - 5
David Yazbek - 5
Leonard Bernstein - 5
Cy Coleman - 5
Stephen Flaherty - 5
Elton John - 3
Richard Adler - 5
Jule Styne - 5
Frank Loesser - 4
Jeanine Tesori - 2 -
William Finn - 2
|
home
|
Stephen Sondheim - 13
Cole Porter - 12 (-)
Alan Menken - 9
Mel Brooks - 8
Lawrence O'Keefe - 7
Frederick Loewe - 7
Jonathan Larson - 7
Jason Robert Brown - 7 (+)
Irving Berlin - 6
Noel Coward - 6
John Kander - 4 (-)
Claude-Michel Schonberg - 5
David Yazbek - 5
Leonard Bernstein - 5
Cy Coleman - 5
Stephen Flaherty - 5
Elton John - 3
Richard Adler - 5
Jule Styne - 5
Frank Loesser - 4
William Finn - 3
Jeanine Tesori - 4 (+)
|
Salome
|
correcting home's mistakes as well)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Stephen Sondheim - 13
Cole Porter - 14 +
Alan Menken - 9
Mel Brooks - 8
Lawrence O'Keefe - 5 -
Frederick Loewe - 7
Jonathan Larson - 7
Jason Robert Brown - 7
Irving Berlin - 6
Noel Coward - 9 +
John Kander - 4
Claude-Michel Schonberg - 5
David Yazbek - 5
Leonard Bernstein - 5
Cy Coleman - 5
Stephen Flaherty - 5
Elton John - 2 -
Richard Adler - 5
Jule Styne - 5
Frank Loesser - 4
William Finn - 3
Jeanine Tesori - 4
|
Buff Daddy
|
Stephen Sondheim - 13
Cole Porter - 15 (+)
Alan Menken - 9
Mel Brooks - 8
Lawrence O'Keefe - 5
Frederick Loewe - 7
Jonathan Larson - 7
Jason Robert Brown - 7
Irving Berlin - 6
Noel Coward - 9
John Kander - 4
Claude-Michel Schonberg - 5
David Yazbek - 5
Leonard Bernstein - 5
Cy Coleman - 5
Stephen Flaherty - 5
Elton John - 1 (-)
Richard Adler - 5
Jule Styne - 5
Frank Loesser - 4
William Finn - 3
Jeanine Tesori - 4
|
Salome
|
Stephen Sondheim - 13 +
Cole Porter - 15
Alan Menken - 9
Mel Brooks - 8
Lawrence O'Keefe - 4 -
Frederick Loewe - 7
Jonathan Larson - 7
Jason Robert Brown - 7
Irving Berlin - 6
Noel Coward - 10 +
John Kander - 4
Claude-Michel Schonberg - 5
David Yazbek - 5
Leonard Bernstein - 5
Cy Coleman - 5
Stephen Flaherty - 5
Richard Adler - 5
Jule Styne - 5
Frank Loesser - 4
William Finn - 3
Jeanine Tesori - 3 -
(elton gone!)
|
Anno_Domini
|
I know it's a little late to point this out, but try to avoid stacking the deck, and give other people a chance. Salome, only now I'm noticing that about half of the adjustments to the list were done by you, and that somewhat ruins the point.
Stephen Sondheim - 13
Cole Porter - 15
Alan Menken - 9
Mel Brooks - 8
Lawrence O'Keefe - 5 +
Frederick Loewe - 7
Jonathan Larson - 6 -
Jason Robert Brown - 8 +
Irving Berlin - 6
Noel Coward - 10
John Kander - 4
Claude-Michel Schonberg - 5
David Yazbek - 5
Leonard Bernstein - 5
Cy Coleman - 5
Stephen Flaherty - 5
Richard Adler - 5
Jule Styne - 5
Frank Loesser - 4
William Finn - 2 -
Jeanine Tesori - 3
|
Salome
|
i adjusted home's error.)
Stephen Sondheim - 13
Cole Porter - 15
Alan Menken - 9
Mel Brooks - 8
Lawrence O'Keefe - 5 -
Frederick Loewe - 7
Jonathan Larson - 6
Jason Robert Brown - 8
Irving Berlin - 6
Noel Coward - 11 +
John Kander - 4
Claude-Michel Schonberg - 5
David Yazbek - 5
Leonard Bernstein - 5
Cy Coleman - 5
Stephen Flaherty - 5
Richard Adler - 5
Jule Styne - 5
Frank Loesser - 4
William Finn - 1 -
Jeanine Tesori - 3
|
actor
|
+ Sondheim
+ Porter
- Menken
- O'Keefe
Cole Porter - 16
Stephen Sondheim - 14
Noel Coward - 11
Alan Menken - 8
Mel Brooks - 8
Jason Robert Brown - 8
Frederick Loewe - 7
Lawrence Jonathan Larson - 6
Irving Berlin - 6
O'Keefe - 4
Claude-Michel Schonberg - 5
David Yazbek - 5
Leonard Bernstein - 5
Cy Coleman - 5
Stephen Flaherty - 5
Richard Adler - 5
Jule Styne - 5
Frank Loesser - 4
John Kander - 4
Jeanine Tesori - 3
William Finn - 1
|
Buff Daddy
|
+ Porter
- William Finn (eliminated)
Cole Porter - 17
Stephen Sondheim - 14
Noel Coward - 11
Alan Menken - 8
Mel Brooks - 8
Jason Robert Brown - 8
Frederick Loewe - 7
Lawrence Jonathan Larson - 6
Irving Berlin - 6
O'Keefe - 4
Claude-Michel Schonberg - 5
David Yazbek - 5
Leonard Bernstein - 5
Cy Coleman - 5
Stephen Flaherty - 5
Richard Adler - 5
Jule Styne - 5
Frank Loesser - 4
John Kander - 4
Jeanine Tesori - 3
|
wicked_diva
|
How could you guys eliminate Finn?! He's 2nd only to Sondheim in my book.
|
Annie
|
Adler -
Flaherty +
Cole Porter - 17
Stephen Sondheim - 14
Noel Coward - 11
Alan Menken - 8
Mel Brooks - 8
Jason Robert Brown - 8
Frederick Loewe - 7
Lawrence Jonathan Larson - 6
Irving Berlin - 6
Stephen Flaherty - 6
O'Keefe - 4
Claude-Michel Schonberg - 5
David Yazbek - 5
Leonard Bernstein - 5
Cy Coleman - 5
Jule Styne - 5
Richard Adler - 4
Frank Loesser - 4
John Kander - 4
Jeanine Tesori - 3
|
Yip1982
|
I fear that even if I like Les Mis a bit but not that much, I have never felt pleased with the other Boubhil-Schonberg shows, so I think I might have to minus a point for Schonberg.
Cole Porter - 17
Stephen Sondheim - 14
Noel Coward - 11
Alan Menken - 8
Mel Brooks - 8
Jason Robert Brown - 8
Frederick Loewe - 7
Lawrence Jonathan Larson - 6
Irving Berlin - 6
Stephen Flaherty - 6
O'Keefe - 4
Claude-Michel Schonberg - 4 (-)
David Yazbek - 5
Leonard Bernstein - 5
Cy Coleman - 5
Jule Styne - 5
Richard Adler - 4
Frank Loesser - 4
John Kander - 4
Jeanine Tesori - 3
|
Salome
|
Cole Porter - 17
Stephen Sondheim - 14
Noel Coward - 12 +
Alan Menken - 8
Mel Brooks - 8
Jason Robert Brown - 8
Frederick Loewe - 7
Jonathan Larson - 6
Irving Berlin - 6
Stephen Flaherty - 6
O'Keefe - 3 -
Claude-Michel Schonberg - 4
John Kander - 5 +
David Yazbek - 5
Leonard Bernstein - 5
Cy Coleman - 5
Jule Styne - 5
Richard Adler - 4
Frank Loesser - 4
Jeanine Tesori - 2 -
|
