Vaseth
|
Andre or Firmin?Which is your favorite Manager?
|
dramatic_mizfit
|
I can never tell the difference.
|
Mirabelle
|
It depends entirely on the actor in the role. There are a few actors I liked as Andre more than the actor opposite them as Firmin. However, there are several Firmin actors I liked as well. Neither character is a favorite of mine in the show anyhow.
|
Fantine
|
| dramatic_mizfit wrote: | | I can never tell the difference. |
Me neither.
|
AngelicDramaQueen58
|
They are 2 different people ? lol jk
I think one need the other in order to be good
|
dramatic_mizfit
|
| Fantine wrote: | | dramatic_mizfit wrote: | | I can never tell the difference. |
Me neither. |
Good, at least I'm not alone. I love them together but I can't say "Oh, that's Firmin singing now." I just know the 2 Managers are singing.
|
operafantomet
|
I've seen more superb Firmins than Andrés, so I'd go for Monsieur Firmin. Though I like the slightly nevrotic André quite well too.
|
Vaseth
|
| Quote: | | I've seen more superb Firmins than Andrés, so I'd go for Monsieur Firmin. |
Me its the opposite way around.[/quote]
|
Lastnightoftheworld
|
I never know which one is which either. I like the one that wears the skeleton suit to the masquerade ball 
|
dramatic_mizfit
|
| Lastnightoftheworld wrote: | | I never know which one is which either. I like the one that wears the skeleton suit to the masquerade ball |
Yeah, he's hilarious. It must be hard to do that, because it's almost like he's dancing up there naked, what with his costume being just his bones and all.
|
Pounce
|
Re: Andre or Firmin? | Vaseth wrote: | | Which is your favorite Manager? |
The Phantom.
| Lastnightoftheworld wrote: | | I never know which one is which either. I like the one that wears the skeleton suit to the masquerade ball |
The Phantom's was way cooler.
|
Toasterphantom
|
Truthfully, if it comes down to it, I can't choose one. I have very odd veiws on who the managers are and therefore can't really pick. I DO love D.C. Anderson's Andre. I have to say, if its him in it?, ANDRE hands down. But Bruce Winant completed it with an amazing Firmin played perfectly opposite Andre. So I think they need eachother to be great.
|
Paula74
|
Well, as a pair, they do compliment each other nicely. But I have to say I really loved Jeff Keller as Firmin. Especially his deadpan "We need you, too" to Carlotta. And the nights when he'd forget to remove his diamond earring.
|
loulx
|
Firmin is my favorite. He gets the more comical moments out of the pair of them... "And what is it that we're meant to have wrote. [pause]... Written." lol makes me chuckle every time.
|
Salome
|
Firmin is the business manager, Andre the artistic manager.
both are great roles best roles in the show.
|
What Is This Feeling?
|
They are excelent! I personally like Andre a bit better. Which one is the one who usually is more grouchy? They are kinda the comic ones of the shows. Carlotta as well!
|
Futuretonywinner
|
I like Andre better. I don't know why.
|
futuremsdaae
|
I like Firmin. It kinda bothered me that in the movie he wasn't as deadpan and sarcastic as he is in the show. I agree- "We need you too" that is so funny. Ya, I like them both, but Firmin is the best.
|
Phantom On A Budget
|
| Toasterphantom wrote: | | Truthfully, if it comes down to it, I can't choose one. I have very odd veiws on who the managers are and therefore can't really pick. I DO love D.C. Anderson's Andre. I have to say, if its him in it?, ANDRE hands down. But Bruce Winant completed it with an amazing Firmin played perfectly opposite Andre. So I think they need eachother to be great. |
You took the words right out of my mouth! Michael McCoy is also an excellent Firmin opposite D.C.
|
Monsieur D'Arque
|
I was going to comment but then I realized I was thinking of Roger DeBris and Carmen Ghia. Close enough.
|
